/platform/judges/admissions) is the second tab of
Judges. Forge can synthesize new Skills, Agents and Procedures
from operator work and Architect runs. Before one joins the catalog, a panel of Judges scores it
for coherence, duplication, quality, and whether its declared capabilities can resolve. The
proposals waiting for a decision land here, worst-scored first.
The tab opens with platform:read. The decision controls (Admit, Reject, Send back, and the task’s
Claim and Take over) appear only when you hold synthesis:approve.


Judges → Admissions — Forge Console at /platform/judges/admissions
What you can do
- Read the panel’s verdict. Each row shows the kind (Skill, Procedure or Agent), the primitive’s name, the headline verdict and the composite score.
- See why. Why did the panel score this? opens each Judge’s score, confidence and rationale.
- Decide. Add an optional note, then choose Admit, Reject or Send back.
- Claim, release or take over the admission’s task.
Read a row
The composite score runs from 0 to 100; lower means more concerns. The pill (Pass, Needs work or Fail) is the headline verdict. A chip per panel Judge shows that Judge’s score, and the row names when the primitive was proposed. The list shows the 50 worst-scored pending admissions. A link from My Work to an admission outside those 50 shows it first.Decide an admission
- Admit promotes the primitive to
provisional, the same tier a passing Judge verdict lands at. Promotion stops there: admission endorses a primitive but doesn’t confer full trust. Reachingapprovedis earned separately from run telemetry. - Reject deprecates the primitive. It is kept for audit, not deleted.
- Send back records your note and leaves the primitive as it is, so its author can iterate.
synthesis:approve at the
platform scope and is an active person with an email, and it is listed in their
My Work. Admit, Reject and Send back decide it through that
task, so an admission someone else claimed is refused. Take over (with a reason) moves the claim
to you and needs approvals:approve at the platform scope.
Key state to watch
- Composite score. The worst-scored proposals are at the top.
- A primitive that did not move. The note was recorded, but Admit or Reject left the lifecycle unchanged; the row gives the reason.
- A refused decision. The row shows Forge’s reason, for example when someone else holds the claim.

